Regarded by many as one of the finest dining establishment in the Hamptons, our aim is to offer our guests a truly unforgettable dining experience.

We enjoy pampering our guests with superb service within an elegant and charming ambience. The Hotel’s renowned restaurant boasts a formal décor with Empire and early Victorian antiques and furnishings.

The restaurant has four separate candle-lit, silver laden dining rooms: the elegant main dining room with Hunky Page behind the piano, the bar room with a cozy fireplace and beautiful wooden bar for those cold winter evenings, the Victorian Drew Room with prints of Lincoln and Washington and the atrium (garden room) with a skylight and intimate atmosphere – all romantic and cozy settings for a wonderful dining experience.

The American Hotel features an award-winning, inventive, "American-French" cuisine all its own and is led by the exceptional talents of Executive Chef Peter Dunlop, assisted by Robert Siu and Steve Minson. The menus feature creative dishes that bring the enticing flavors of France, Italy, America and Asia to the table. The menus change with the seasons and are always an eclectic blend of local and imported produce. The American Hotel restaurant offers one of the most extensive menus in the Hamptons, appealing to all appetites and tastes.

Our 85 page (1700 selections) award-winning wine list is a Wine Spectator "Grand Award" winner and is a meticulous selection of wine gems from around the globe.

The restaurant has received the DiRoNA Award since 1992 for the highest standards for food, wine and spirits, service, atmosphere and value. Zagat gave the restaurant top ratings and the Hotel is also a recognized partner of the American Express Platinum Fine Dining Program. The Hotel is included into America's Elite 1000.

The Hotel is open year round and dinner is served seven nights a week. The dress code is smart casual. 

Be our guest for Lunch or Dinner and experience why the American Hotel is praised by food and wine critics for its dedication and commitment to excellence.

 
Our reigning pianist, Hunky Page
"There's no such thing as an old stand-by when Hunky Page plays piano. Every song he touches becomes new, as if it had been waiting for him to breathe life into it. He is, without exception, the best." -Roger Rosenblatt